After loving Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre and Villette and preferring her writing over her sisters’, I was really not expecting to dislike The Professor as much as I did. It’s basically the worse version of Villette; through these Charlotte Brontë has proven herself to be very formulaic. Though I suppose she may have realized that The Professor needed improving upon, and chose to alter the story just slightly, expand upon it, and write it from a female protagonist, and voila, we have Villette.
In reading The Professor, I could identify some of the writing techniques Charlotte used in her later novels, but it’s not as polished and refined. The writing itself is not as polished. A lot of inner thoughts are presented in the form of dialogue instead, which reads amateurish, and the real dialogue could be a bit tedious. There’s a bit of melodrama that seems unnatural and unearned. There was a passive narrative of some events that should have been active to help the pace and chronology, the latter of which was sometimes questionable.
There was no index of full French-to-English translations in the back of my edition of The Professor like there was in my edition of Villette, so I didn’t fully understand everything. It wasn’t till around page 100 when my interest was finally piqued enough to start google translating the many French sentences, and that was around the time Frances Henri was introduced into the narrative. She was the most interesting part of the entire book. I liked the last part of the novel a lot better than the first because it contained more of her. Our protagonist was very underdeveloped, easily forgotten and dull because he didn’t have a strong narrative voice.
Which leads me to the conclusion that Charlotte is much better at writing through the eyes of a female protagonist. There was a poem included as written from Frances, but struck me as very confessional from Charlotte herself, of her own real-life experience with the married professor that she supposedly based the relationships in The Professor and Villette around. Charlotte was not brave enough in her first novel to write from a similar female perspective as her own, relating experiences that so closely aligned with her own. That came with time and showed itself in the stronger characters of Jane Eyre and Lucy Snowe. Charlotte has more insight into her female protagonists, and their narrative voice is part of what makes the other novels so special.
There was an Emma excerpt at the back of my edition. It was the last novel Charlotte started before she died. I liked the 20 pages included. It already proved itself a more fascinating story than The Professor, so it’s unfortunate Charlotte never got to finish it.
My ranking of the Brontë novels so far:
- Jane Eyre
- Villette
- Tenant of Wildfell Hall
- Wuthering Heights
- The Professor