This story sent me down a commentary rabbit hole and through a whirlwind of conflicting impressions. It’s taken me at least a month of on-and-off writing to complete this review because I can’t order my impressions and thoughts. And I’m still not sure exactly how I feel about either the book or the movie version of The Virgin Suicides.
I watched the movie directed by Sophia Coppola a few months before I read the book by Jeffrey Eugenides. After watching, I saw comments about how girls related to or tried to see themselves in the Lisbon sisters, how the aesthetic of the film was adopted by society for fashion and movie trends and how we illustrate and understand girlhood, and about the movie’s “relaxing atmosphere.” And I was disturbed. I was having trouble understanding how any girl could find anything relatable in the voyeuristic, fetishized portrayal of teenage girls through the eyes of obsessive teenage boys. And I found it deeply ironic how the audience chose to adopt a male’s perspective as their own (mis)representation.
The Virgin Suicides is Jeffrey Eugenides’ debut novel and follows a group of mostly anonymous boys who relate to us the story of 5 sisters who all commit suicide over the course of a little over a year. We never get the girls’ perspectives; we only ever have the opportunity of hearing the boys’ speculation and evidence obtained through stalking-like behavior and years of obsessive investigating the past, well into adulthood.
Sophia Coppola then adapted the story into film, keeping the male POV. And surprisingly, I’m more disturbed by the female rendition of the story about the “male gaze” than the male’s.
Jeffrey Eugenides wrote the story with such skill. There is so much symbolism, imagery, irony, and other such literary devices that I will get into below that make the book, if not pleasant because of the unpleasant topic, a stimulating and engaging read. He makes it abundantly clear that the entire narration is unreliable, from the narrators themselves to the people they interview. Everyone is an unreliable gossiper and observer. Everything is uncertain and unclear, even the photographs. Eugenides repeats the theme of sights and images being distorted through “tricks of the light” to indicate false perceptions.
- “Her head appears to be on fire but that is only a trick of the light” (3)
- “for the first few seconds the Lisbon girls were only a patch of glare like a congregation of angels. Then, however, our eyes got used to the light and informed us of something we had never realized: the Lisbon girls were all different people”
- “a distracting light source invades from the left” in their homecoming photo
- Of the photographs of the girls in their treehouse: “dim from time and weather so that all we could make out were the phosphorescent outlines of the girls’ bodies, each a different glowing letter of an unknown alphabet”
This unreliability helps the audience distrust everything the narrators claim, so their perception of the girls is not taken as fact. It’s hard to distrust a narration to that extent when it takes you inside the Lisbon house and you can see everything with your own eyes as in the film.
Eugenides writes sensory imagery that pervades every page. The flies are thick, the smell of the decaying Lisbon house provides a sense of disgust, the book feels grimy. Every mention of the Lisbon girls is accompanied by perversion as the boys sexualize them in some way or another. From the very first few pages, a symbol of purity is often juxtaposed with lust: “picture of the Virgin Mary she held against her budding chest,” “a crucifix draped with a brassiere.” Cecilia is always wearing her white wedding dress, an image of innocence and purity that is always connected with its imminent loss during the marriage night. Once the boys see the girls close up, they think “their faces looked indecently revealed, as though we were used to seeing women in veils.”
The boys fetishize the girls’ menstruation and fantasize that a tampon was “fresh from the insides of one of the Lisbon girls,” they mention the “unstimulating stage of the girls’ infancy,” because the girls are only interesting to them as an object of sexual fantasy, one boy talked of copping a feel of Cecilia’s dead body lying in her casket if he could have done it with a peer audience, and in the shockingly unlivable environment of the Lisbon basement, which had flooded and never been cleaned since the night of Cecilia’s death almost a year earlier, with visible mouse droppings, moldy punch and sherbert, withered balloons, cobwebs, a dead mouse in the floodwater, one of the boys says “If I could just feel one of them up just once.” Eugenides lets you dwell in the imagery of purity, grief, or devastation and makes the boys’ teenage perversion that much more outrageous by contrast.
The movie, however, with a female director, adds a romanticization layer by making everything so beautiful and dreamy. Everything in the book was coated in dirt. Even the fantasies about the girls were coated in dirty perversion, but in the movie, the fantasies are glamorous montages of teenage girls that belong in perfume ads. No wonder the young girls in the audience wanted to be those girls and adopt their style. Coppola doesn’t linger on contrasting imagery, she makes it more light and airy. You see the months-old, half-eaten sandwich on the staircase or the preserved party in a leaky basement, but all of it is passed over, happening in the background. She doesn’t at all show the moldy food or floodwater in the basement, toning down the girls’ neglect and unlivable environment and focusing on a dreamy aesthetic, avoiding Eugenides’ sardonic tone and shying away from the dirtier material.
I even found it a bit creepy how Coppola hyperfixates on Lux, or her darling Kirsten Dunst, in the movie. I thought the film was mostly about Lux the first time I watched it, with her sisters as more secondary characters. Lux is the last to go in the film, and effectively had the last word, whereas it was Mary in the book. It felt like Coppola was subconsciously obsessing over an actress or friend in a film about obsession. Not that there’s anything wrong with having a favorite actress in a movie you’re directing, but it was deeply ironic.
Eugenides gave the sisters physical flaws that the boys looked over, and they sexualized the girls anyways. The boys gave unflattering descriptions when they viewed the sisters up close, like sallow complexions, upper lip fuzz, long necks, two left feet. Only Lux accorded with the romanticized image, but the boys obsessed over the ugly parts of the sisters too, like their ugly palms and the scent of their exertion at the dance, the “pumice calluses on their big toes.” These imperfections weren’t present in the film. All of the sisters as shown in the film were beautiful, remaining romanticized and airbrushed, the fantasized perception of teenage girls rather than the reality.
I think adapting The Virgin Suicides to film was a mistake. There were so many literary devices carefully crafted that made the story ideal for written format. Not all literary devices translate to film. And in a story that involves the sexualization of young girls, I think you have to be ultra careful. It reminds me of the much more controversial and serious adaptation of Lolita. In order to portray the story of a pedophilic relationship with an underage girl, the two main adaptations each cast an underage girl to play Lolita, and each depicted her as the pedophile Humbert sees her instead of as the child she truly was, providing visual sexual stimulation using real-life girls and putting them in compromising positions. Something Nabokov was strictly against. Nabokov so carefully constructed that story to portray an innocent child being abused, and the films portrayed a child seductress, because they were trying to portray the narrator’s image of Lolita. In the same way, Eugenides carefully constructed a story of five sisters being misrepresented by unreliable, horny teenage boys, and the film portrayed teenage sex figures, because they were trying to portray the narrators’ image of the sisters.
I think I’m in the minority when it comes to judging the movie as an insensitive portrayal of the book. It’s a cult classic, with many people praising it for precisely what I find fault. They praise its ability to avoid the trap of romanticizing female suffering, and I’m not sure it did. Or rather, I’m not sure it did it as successfully as the book.
There is so much commentary about female purity wrapped up in this story. Not only the juxtaposition of symbols related to purity and lust, the constant sexualization of the girls by their teenage voyeurs, the pervading impression that the girls shrink from this perception, but there’s also the conveyance that the death of a young girl is also a preservation of innocence, no potential for corruption. Tragedy is romanticized into an aesthetic of a preserved flower, offered up in the form of a young girl’s death. The book isn’t called The Sister Suicides, The Girl’s Suicides. It’s called The Virgin Suicides for a reason. The connection with innocence, purity, the Virgin Mary and religion, and the intentional preservation of that state through self-killing, was by design.
In her coffin, “Cecilia’s face [was] rouged for the first and last time ever.” My first impression was that apparently Mrs. Lisbon thought Cecilia couldn’t be sexualized in death (if only she knew what the boys present at the funeral were thinking), but it’s also emblematic of the desire to keep the young girl tragically beautiful. It wasn’t considered appropriate to adorn her daughter while she was living, but it was important in death to make her pretty.
Even their very suicides were adapted to fit the image of innocence: “Officially, Cecilia’s death was listed in church records as an “accident,” as were the other girls’ a year later. When we asked Father Moody about this, he said, ‘We didn’t want to quibble. How do you know she didn’t slip?’ When we brought up the sleeping pills, and the noose, and the rest of it, he said ‘Suicide, as a mortal sin, is a matter of intent. It’s very difficult to know what was in those girls’ hearts. What they were really trying to do.’” They somehow idealized what should be stark clear in denial that the girls could be anything but sinless and inculpable, as if the girls could not know their own minds. And one of the boy’s outrageously ridiculous and insulting analysis of Cecilia’s suicide: “When she jumped, she probably thought she’d fly.” They projected their idea of naivete onto the girls so they wouldn’t have to confront an obviously discordant reality.
The girls internalized this external perception that they had to be the perfect image of innocent, feminine manageability. When her mother made her get rid of her rock records, Lux slid her record collection down the stairs: “She acted like she was going to whiz them down. But she always grabbed them before they got out of control.” She made such an effort to remain manageable even while trying to express rebellion, trying not to be too unwieldy, too dark. They were stifled and crushed under the expectations of everyone else of how they should act. At the homecoming dance, Therese said: “‘Cecilia was weird, but we’re not.’ And then: ‘We just want to live. If anyone would let us.’”
Even while expressing their own individuality in their clothes, words, actions, the rest of the world objectified and unified them into one. They were always being confused for one another. Even at their joint funeral, Father Moody kept losing track of which girl was in which grave so he kept the eulogies “general.” They never had the chance of being distinct personalities that the audience could come to know and relate to.
The audience was never meant to relate to them at all except through the inevitable projection of self onto fictional characters. Eugenides himself said, “Over the years, I’ve come to believe that the narrative voice of the novel, and the voyeuristic attention the boys maintain on the girls, creates a negative space where readers can project their own imaginations. The Lisbon girls are never seen from the inside: their mental and emotional life is a matter of conjecture and misinterpretation. Like suicide itself, the truth of their lives is ultimately unknowable.”
In his novel, Eugenides explores the inadequacy of our attempts to understand and address suicide through sardonic humor, like the thought process behind choosing green for a pamphlet about suicide. Parts of the book were actually funny in a dark way. Even if some of the same lines were in the movie, the humor didn’t come across the same way. And the dark, subtle humor of the book never felt disrespectful, because it was never left alone to make light of dark material, but was accompanied by depth, like how educating ourselves on our own minds can be counterintuitive: “a local television show focused on the subject of teenage suicide, inviting two girls and one boy to explain their reasons for attempting it. We listened to them, but it was clear they’d received too much therapy to know the truth. Their answers sounded rehearsed, relying on concepts of self-esteem and other words clumsy on their tongues.”
There’s an ongoing metaphor connecting the diseased trees in the neighborhood to the Lisbon sisters. The disease is infectious, and in order to stop the spread, they are being cut down. After Cecilia’s death, the city workers come to cut down the tree in the Lisbon sisters’ front yard, and all of the sisters come out and plant themselves around the tree in protest. On one hand, it’s easy to understand their anxiety, because they had so little to feel protective over. Their home and yard was the entirety of their lives at that point. But, some of the neighborhood thought they were so protective over it because it was Cecilia’s favorite tree. When the workers tried to get the parents to intercede with the children, Mrs. Lisbon asks how they know the tree was sick. The worker replies, “‘Believe me. We know. It’s got yellow leaves. It had yellow leaves. We cut that branch off already.’” I was instantly reminded of the use of yellow to describe Cecilia’s eyes throughout the book, which I had found strange. Her eyes are described as yellow on p1, and then on pages 5 and 27, Cecilia is said to have “sunflower eyes.” And throughout the book, Cecilia’s mental health and suicide was described as infecting the other girls till they eventually committed suicide themselves. The trees were all cut down, and both the trees and the Lisbon sisters were absent from the neighborhood.
The majority of the book is quite frustrating, intentionally so. And creepy. It intentionally romanticizes female suffering through the narrators’ limiting perceptions: “Added to their loveliness was a new mysterious suffering, perfectly silent.” And then it adds layers upon layers of unreliability and unlikeable narrators to make the audience question that prevalent tendency in society. It places us as an audience in the narrators’ shoes, the shoes of boys who play rock, paper, scissors to decide who gets to run away with the girls in a display of ridiculous immaturity as the girls are facing a crisis, who are obsessed even as adults with the memories and the artifacts of the Lisbon sisters. They don’t want people to touch the photographs, as they are too precious, they keep the same part in their hair as Bonnie once arranged it, they welcome reeking smells to call to their minds the smell of decay that once came from the Lisbon house, they claim they’re happier in dreams of the Lisbon girls than they are with their living wives, they say “it is always that pale wraith [of Lux on the roof] we make love to.” These are our sources of information, and we’re placed in the position of becoming intimately acquainted with the story of the Lisbon sisters through boys who never had the right to the information and who could never be relied upon to convey that information accurately. Through narrative layers, we are indirectly made complicit in the continuous objectification the boys make of the Lisbon girls and their memory.
I respect the amount of thought Eugenides put into crafting his story. I appreciate how much it and the film adaptation made me think, though I’m not sure if my impressions accord with either the author’s or the director’s intentions. Or if I can say I “like” either the book or the movie. I’m glad I read it, though, and I think I’m more likely to revisit the book in the future rather than the movie.