Frenchman’s Creek by Daphne du Maurier was mainly just entertaining; I didn’t really take it seriously. It’s not a psychological thriller or a gothic, atmospheric mystery like My Cousin Rachel or Rebecca; it’s a rompy pirate adventure and romance. To be honest, the plot kind of reminds me of a modern carefree, throwaway smut read, minus the smut (because of early 20th century sensibilities) and definitely more elevated because of du Maurier’s writing.
The protagonist was rather unlikeable. In the opening scene, I felt surely this woman, so domineering to her servants, couldn’t be our protagonist, but she was. I disliked her less as the novel went on, but mostly because du Maurier hid her interactions with sympathetic characters that Dona might otherwise have been rude to, and focused on her attitude toward either people Dona herself sympathized with or the pompous upper class, which we can all easily ridicule. But her character was primarily selfish, judgmental, and spoiled. And her disinterest in her own children was a tad offensive to my sensibilities. The children were barely included in the novel, and then just as a bare reminder of her burdensome responsibilities and of her toddler son’s cuteness, seemingly the one attachment she had to her family. I got the distinct impression she just found her daughter an annoying presence.
Both Dona and the pirate love interest made very questionable choices and undoubtedly had questionable morals. I never really liked Dona, and the pirate would perhaps have been more interesting outside of Dona’s selfish, romance-centered lens. However, I was still rooting for Dona and her pirate lover to not get caught by authorities. And I was rooting for Dona to get away from her boring, infantile husband.
Dona’s criminal adventures, all done clad in boy clothes, were definitely unrealistic and unbelievable, but I didn’t care very much. I was along for the ride at that point. And I was genuinely curious to see what her decision at the end was going to be. After she had experienced all of that freedom and moral inattentiveness, was she going to choose to ride away with her pirate into the sunset, or was she going to return to her high society life and stay a mother to her kids?
Ranking her novels that I’ve read so far:
- Rebecca
- My Cousin Rachel
- Frenchman’s Creek
- Jamaica Inn
- Mary Anne
Rebecca ranks the highest, being one of my favorite books of all time. My Cousin Rachel comes next for its admirable psychological mind twists. The rest of the books lack the subtlety of these higher rankings. Frenchman’s Creek ranks higher than Jamaica Inn because I could understand the protagonist’s motivations more (even if I might not condone or admire them), and the characters felt a bit less caricature-like. Mary Anne ranks last as a dud.
Should I read Scapegoat or House on the Strand next or should I give up my du Maurier exploration? I haven’t found another Rebecca high.